Skip to content
Journal ArticleRandomized Controlled TrialComparative StudyScandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports·Graded and published ·Last edited

Drop Sets vs. Rest-Pause: No Clear Winner in the Gym

Graded Moderate — a random assignment of 23 trained adults over eight weeks; with so few people smaller differences could be missed, and there was no group without training.

Design
Randomized controlled trial
Participants
23
Duration
8 weeks
Funding
No funding reported
Key Insight

Strength and fat-free mass grew over eight weeks with both drop sets and rest-pause, with no clear difference between the two methods.


Gym-goers who want to push harder often use one of two tricks. With a drop set, you lower the weight after a tough set and keep going. With rest-pause, you rest for a moment, then carry on with the same weight. In a small head-to-head comparison, both groups got stronger over eight weeks, with no clear difference between the methods.

Researchers assigned 23 adults aged 18 to 35 at random to one method. All had at least a year of strength training behind them. They trained twice a week under supervision and followed a set eating plan. Afterwards, the drop-set group could bench press 12.3 kilograms more on average, the rest-pause group 9.5 kilograms. Muscle and other fat-free tissue grew by just over a kilogram in both groups. Fat mass barely changed.

The groups were very small, so smaller differences, for example in the bench press, may have gone undetected. There was no group that skipped training. Almost everyone was a young man; only three women took part. Whether the results hold for women, older adults or over longer periods is open.

Conflict of Interest Disclosure: One author formerly sat on the scientific advisory board of a fitness equipment maker; another has received speaking fees.

Disclaimer: Research summaries are provided for informational purposes only and do not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your health routine.