Skip to content
Journal ArticleSystematic ReviewMeta-AnalysisReviewAgeing research reviews·Graded and published ·Last edited

Strength per Unit of Muscle: Resistance Training Stands Out

Graded Moderate — an analysis pooling 41 randomized trials with 3,141 people; results varied widely between the individual trials.

Design
Meta-analysis
Participants
3,141
Duration
—
Funding
Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development
Key Insight

Resistance training improved strength relative to muscle mass in people aged 60 and older.


Too little strength for the amount of muscle a person has is seen as a core feature of age-related muscle loss. An analysis that pooled 41 trials found that resistance training improved this measure in people aged 60 and older. For aerobic exercise, combined programs and nutritional supplements, no clear improvement was detected.

The researchers pooled trials with 3,141 older adults in total. In every trial, people were chosen at random for a program or a comparison group. Each program lasted at least eight weeks. The trials measured muscle strength divided by muscle mass. Approaches included resistance training, aerobic exercise, both together, exercise plus supplements, supplements alone and eating fewer calories.

Results varied widely between trials, including for resistance training. So the true size of the effect is uncertain. No clear benefit does not mean aerobic exercise or supplements do nothing; the data are not enough to judge. The authors consider resistance training the most effective approach and call for more well-designed trials.

Conflict of Interest Disclosure: One author has applied for a patent in Japan on a program that analyzes muscle with ultrasound.

Disclaimer: Research summaries are provided for informational purposes only and do not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your health routine.